In my previous post I laid out the deeper causes of our present affordability crisis and contended they are exceptionally poorly understood by the wider public. For that, we can blame a complete and utter breakdown of the knowledge system informing American voters. The term “knowledge system” was coined, as far as I’m aware, by Alex Epstein in his excellent book Fossil Future. Epstein defines it as “the people and institutions we rely upon to research, synthesize, disseminate, and evaluate expert knowledge.” His beef with it is that information is distorted as it’s being disseminated from academic institutions to government institutions, NGOs, and then to the media and, ultimately, to average Americans.
As its title would suggest, Epstein’s book uses the term “knowledge system” in the context of climate change policies. But the principle can be applied to U.S. monetary and fiscal policy just as well. For it seems to me — and the midterm election results made this glaringly clear — that very few people understand the mechanism by which the price of everything exploded during COVID and its aftermath. Economically speaking, we are very much still reeling from the pandemic. In the meanwhile, the government is $40 trillion in the hole and we are headed full speed towards a fiscal cliff of epic proportions. And nobody is talking about this — not conservatives, not progressives, and certainly not politicians of whichever party in Washington, DC. If this isn’t evidence of a complete breakdown of the knowledge system informing our democratic decisions and our government’s economic policies, I don’t know what is.
One point not touched upon in my previous post is the macro-economic effects of perpetually low interest rates. A while back, this post appeared on Oren Cass’ Commonplace magazine. In it, Brij Khurana lays out what the last two decades of Fed policy actually produced. His conclusion — hardly earth-shattering — is that the Federal Reserve’s multi-decade experiment with ultra-low interest rates didn’t generate productive investment, but asset price inflation.
The core of Khurana’s argument is that, whereas debt can finance productive investments, at the moment “each additional dollar of borrowing is generating less than a dollar of GDP growth. … And unproductive debt prompts a vicious cycle, in which higher debt levels divert cash flows from investment to interest payments.” Debt is being used largely to “[boost] return on equity and [achieve] higher valuations, as investors seeing a lack of investment opportunities post-[Great Financial Crisis] [reward] financial engineering over long-term capital formation.” He calls this trend “financialization”.
“Another consequence of chronically low interest rates,” Khurana writes, “has been elevated asset prices.” This is not necessarily an issue “if their growth follows the economy’s.” But, he argues, “after holding steady below 400% of GDP during the second half of the 20th century, U.S. household wealth surged to almost 600% in the 2020s. Rising wealth has exacerbated income inequality and gains have been concentrated among older households—particularly the Baby Boom generation, which holds roughly half of U.S. wealth.”
This is another point the public fails to understand: inflation is the stealthy and slow killer of the lower classes, whose net worth is typically low or altogether absent. People with money invest their dollars into assets, whose values then inflate. This is also why the stock market has been going gangbusters in the last half decade. But this asset price inflation removes the bottom rungs from the ladder of those needing to borrow in order to buy their first home or make their first capital business investments. Our fiscal and monetary policies have produced societal bifurcation.
In his podcast, Victor Davis Hanson argued last week that the economy under Trump II has been vastly better than under Biden in 2022, when we all expected a Red Wave in the midterms which nevertheless failed to materialize. Inflation is down, the economy is growing, and the stock market is way up, after all. I’m second to none in my admiration of VDH, but this rosy presentation paints only half the picture. We now find ourselves further along the same path charted by Sleepy Joe, and the bottom 50 or 60 percent of the population is not fairing well. It’s true that our 401(k)s are doing fine (though the stock market’s had some rough months lately), but that’s of little consolation if you spend your days mopping floors at Burger King or searching Indeed for your first job after college.
It’s little wonder voters, particularly the young, are adrift. Upward mobility — synonymous with the ideal of the American Dream — has stalled. And the bandwidth within which politicians can operate to remediate the causes of this standstill is narrowing rapidly as a result of benefits and expectations erected in the past. As I mentioned the other day, the collapse of Social Security is right around the corner, and no painless responses are available to avert this catastrophe. The only real options available are: a) making sharp cuts to the program today; b) allowing existing law to trigger automatic cuts to SS recipients; or c) a combination of both approaches.
The first step would be to acknowledge the problem. As so often — and I say this as a three-time Trump voter — our president has been his own worst enemy on this front. Ronald Reagan would have been able to explain all of the above in very clear terms to the voter, but not The Donald, a president about as interested in teaching as the Gipper was in tariffs. The closest Trump has come to addressing affordability was to promise lower prices, which was both unrealistic and foolish (not to mention ruinous, had they materialized across the board). As for the Democrats, it goes without saying that they will attempt to do the opposite of what is necessary to stem the tide. Our media are too dumb and partisan to even understand what’s happening, let alone explain it to the public. And so, the list of people who could affect meaningful change is rather thin.
It seems to me that liberal democracy’s biggest enemy is cynicism among voters about the democratic process, a sense that it doesn’t matter for whom they vote, for the outcome will be the same regardless — and not positive. If citizens keep oscillating between the conventional left and the conventional right but nothing changes for them, one of these days they’ll vote the next Vladimir Lenin or Adolf Hitler into office — whatever politician comes along for whom democracy is a mere train from which to hop off once it reaches its desired destination (to use Recep Erdogan’s famous and colorful analogy).
In other words, like France, Great Britain and Belgium, our country is rapidly becoming ungovernable. And for that, we can blame an elite which would rather argue about the outrage of the day than talk about proper management of our federal budget and money supply.